Immigration and U.S. Population Growth: An Environmental Perspective (NPG Special Report)

• Mark Nowak
• September 1, 1997
• Forum Papers
• Forum Paper
• 0 Comments

Click here for a downloadable, printable PDF version.

An NPG Forum Paper
by Mark W. Nowak
September 1997

Controversy over U.S. immigration policy is by no means new to the political landscape. Since 1819, when Congress passed the first significant law regulating immigration into the United States, successive debates over immigration have stirred emotions and polarized perceptions. It is not surprising, then, to find that environ­mentalists, confronted by the issue with in­creasing frequency, are by no means in agreement about the relationship between immigration and the environment.

On the one hand are those who argue that immigration, notwithstanding the benefits it provides, is fundamentally a form of popu­lation growth. Therefore, say supporters of this position, levels of immigration must be reduced (and fertility held at replace­ment-level or below) if we are to move toward environmental sustainability in the United States.

Others argue that treating immigration as an environmental issue is a wrong-headed approach to environmental protec­tion. Rather than focusing on inimigra­lion, say these proponents, the environment would be better served by ad­dressing issues such as Americans’ hyper-consuming lifestyle. which are more to blame for our environmental ills.

It’s true that numerous factors—includ­ing the high consumption rates of Americans — contribute substantially to environmental degradation, but diminishing or discounting the real role that immigration plays make little sense. All other factors being equal, the en­vironmental consequences of human activity increase with the growth of the population. This essential relationship is nearly universally recognized— particularly among environmen­tal and population groups—as one of the fun­damental bases for providing international population stabilization funding.

….Continue reading the full Forum paper by clicking here.